One of the most significant and interesting facts
about the Crucible is the way that the hangings and confessions are carried out
and how the different people react to being threatened with death. Arthur
Miller creates a distinction between the characters who face their death in
order to protect their name, and those who admit to witchcraft in order to save
their own life. Characters like Goody Proctor and the Corey’s who refuse
to confess to witchcraft are presented as strong characters who have a deep
seated moral compass. Characters like Tituba, who confess are presented as weak
and self-serving, choosing to protect their own life at the expense of others.
John Proctor has a revelation of his own, choosing to confess, until he
realizes that doing so would ruin his name and force others to go through the
same ordeal as he did. Arthur Miller uses this as an allegory to McCarthyism and
about those who were blacklisted for refusing to testify or give other names.
In this sense, those who refuse to testify in the witch hunt are meant to be
seen as stronger characters. However, when compared to The Wall and how the prisoners threatened with death lost all
attachment to their world, it would not be much of a stretch, in that context,
to argue that the characters in The
Crucible who accept their death were susceptible to the mental torture of
being threatened with death, and through that lost their attachment to the
world, which would go against the theme Arthur Miller attempts to portray.
Great, straightforward analysis of the division between those who saved their names and those who saved their lives. My favorite part of your response was the comparison to "The Wall." You made a very good point about how the Crucible characters similarly became detached from the world and the morals they held dear when tortured with the news of death. In a way, the division seen in Crucible that you mentioned early in your response can also be seen in "The Wall." It makes one wonder if such a division universally exists in scenarios involving the mental torture of a death sentence.
ReplyDelete